Walk into any gym changing room and you will hear strong opinions about protein powder. Whey is often described as the "gold standard", while soy is sometimes dismissed as second best or surrounded by worries about hormones. With Veganuary approaching and more people trying dairy-free eating, it is worth looking at what the evidence actually says. This guide compares soy and whey protein on quality, muscle building, digestion, taste and the common myths, so you can choose the one that suits you.
Soy and whey at a glance
Whey protein comes from milk. It is the liquid left over when milk is turned into cheese, filtered and dried into a powder. It is sold as concentrate, isolate or hydrolysed whey, depending on how much it is processed.
Soy protein comes from soya beans. The beans are dehulled, defatted and processed into a concentrated protein powder. It is one of the few plant proteins that provides all nine essential amino acids in useful amounts.
Both can count towards your daily protein target. Protein contributes to a growth in muscle mass and to the maintenance of muscle mass, and it also contributes to the maintenance of normal bones. Those authorised claims apply whether the protein comes from milk or from plants.
Protein quality: are they both "complete"?
Protein quality depends on two things: the amino acid profile and how well the protein is digested. Both whey and soy contain all the essential amino acids, which is why both score highly on the older PDCAAS quality measure.
On the newer DIAAS measure, whey tends to score slightly higher, mainly because it is very easily digested and rich in leucine. Leucine is the amino acid most closely linked with switching on muscle protein synthesis after training. Whey typically contains around 10–11% leucine, while soy protein is closer to 8%.
In practical terms, this gap is small. You can compensate by using a slightly larger serving of soy protein, or simply by making sure your overall daily protein intake is adequate.
Which is better for building muscle?
This is the question most people really care about. A 2018 meta-analysis by Messina and colleagues, published in the International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism, pooled randomised trials in which people did resistance training while supplementing with either soy or animal protein (mostly whey). It found no significant difference in gains in strength or lean body mass between the two.
That fits with a wider message from sports nutrition research: total daily protein, spread across meals, matters more than the exact source. For most people who lift weights, an intake of roughly 1.6g of protein per kilogram of body weight per day is a commonly used target, alongside a progressive training programme and enough calories.
Where whey may have a modest edge is in the hour or two after a single session, because it is digested quickly and delivers more leucine per gram. Over weeks and months of consistent training, studies suggest the difference largely disappears.
The soy and hormones myth
Soya beans contain isoflavones, plant compounds sometimes called phytoestrogens because their structure resembles oestrogen. This has led to a persistent worry that soy protein lowers testosterone or "feminises" men.
The research does not support this at normal dietary intakes. A 2021 meta-analysis by Reed and colleagues reviewed dozens of clinical studies and found that neither soy protein nor isoflavone intake affected testosterone, free testosterone or oestrogen levels in men. Soy has been a staple protein in many cuisines for centuries, and modern soy protein powders contain moderate amounts of isoflavones.
As with any food, people with a soy allergy should avoid it, and anyone with a specific medical concern should speak to their GP.
Digestion, allergies and intolerances
Whey
Whey concentrate contains a small amount of lactose. Many people with mild lactose intolerance tolerate it well, but those who are sensitive may prefer an isolate or a plant protein. Whey is a milk product, so it is not suitable for people with a milk allergy or for vegans.
Soy
Soy protein is naturally dairy-free and lactose-free, which makes it a practical choice for vegans and people avoiding milk. Soy is one of the 14 major allergens in the UK, so it is not suitable for anyone with a soy allergy.
Taste, texture and how to use them
Whey usually mixes very smoothly and has a creamy, milky taste. Soy protein is slightly thicker and can have a mild nutty note, which works well with chocolate, cookie and coffee flavours and in smoothies, porridge or baking.
For a dairy-free option, Veganstrong Soy Protein provides 26g of protein per 30g serving, is sugar-free and gluten-free, and comes in Cookies and Chocolate flavours. It mixes with water or your favourite plant-based drink in a few seconds.
A 100% plant-based soy protein powder with 26g of protein per 30g serving, sugar-free and gluten-free, in Cookies and Chocolate flavours.
View product →If you eat dairy and prefer the taste and texture of whey, Wheystrong Protein is a whey concentrate made with whey from Italian suppliers and the DigeZyme® multi-enzyme complex, and it works well in shakes, pancakes and protein porridge.
How to choose: a quick decision guide
- Vegan, dairy-free or milk allergy: choose soy protein (unless you are allergic to soy).
- Lactose-sensitive but not vegan: soy protein or a whey isolate are both reasonable options.
- No dietary restrictions and you love a creamy shake: whey is a great fit.
- Trying Veganuary: soy protein is an easy swap that keeps your protein intake steady.
- Budget-focused: compare the cost per 25g of protein, not the cost per tub.
Getting the most from either protein
- Aim to spread protein across three to five meals or snacks a day, with roughly 20–40g at each.
- Use a shake when food alone makes it hard to hit your target, not as a replacement for meals.
- Pair protein with a progressive strength programme; protein supports the work, it does not replace it.
- Keep an eye on total calories, especially if your goal is to gain muscle.
Products mentioned in this article
A 100% plant-based soy protein powder with 26g of protein per 30g serving, sugar-free and gluten-free, in Cookies and Chocolate flavours.
View product →
A whey protein concentrate made with whey from Italian suppliers and the DigeZyme® multi-enzyme complex, in Chocolate and Cookies flavours.
View product →Frequently asked questions
Is soy protein as good as whey for muscle growth?
Research comparing the two during resistance training has found similar gains in strength and lean mass when total protein intake is adequate.
Does soy protein lower testosterone?
A 2021 meta-analysis found no effect of soy protein or isoflavones on testosterone or oestrogen levels in men at typical intakes.
Can I mix soy and whey protein?
Yes. Some people use whey after training and soy at other times of day. What matters most is your total daily protein intake.
Is soy protein good for women?
Yes. Soy protein is a high-quality protein suitable for women and men. If you have a specific medical condition, speak to your GP.
How much protein powder should I take a day?
Most people use one or two servings a day to top up food. Work out your total protein target first, then see how much your meals already provide.
Food supplements should not be used as a substitute for a varied, balanced diet and a healthy lifestyle.